Removed by mod
USA has the Espionage Act. A violation of this law can be punishable by death, and whistleblowers and journalists have been targeted under this law in the past.
Roy Cohn, the guy who mentored Trump and was McCarthy’s second AND had his own Lavender Scare (while he himself was gay) got his claim to fame when he sent a Jewish couple to death over this exact thing
Removed by mod
Does anyone else see a suspicious disconnect here? The actual legislation cited is a prohibition about “any intelligence cooperation with the Mossad”. And what’s more, this complaint is coming from Euronews, a news agency which is likely hostile to the regime. Whatever you think about the regime, I am pretty sure that cooperation with the enemy in wartime is maximally punishable in any country.
So my takeaway when I read this piece was that it sounded like a fox complaining that teeth and claws are forbidden in the chicken coop.
You’re halfway there. Now ask yourself why a civilian has a distinction in their language when they’re describing world leaders? Why is Iran ruled by a “regime” and any is Israel seeking “regime” change? Why are Western countries not ruled by “regimes”?
Funny how you equate the Iranian regime with chickens. You know, yhay same regime that murders people slowly by slowly Hanging them from a crane, just and only just because they loved the wrong person. I believe the handmaid’s tale has a good example scene of this.
Yes, Israel is committing a genocide, USA is evil, but do you really want to apologize for yet another evil, then?
Funny how the west is friends with saudis which is an as bloody regime
Removed by mod
Removed by mod
I believe the handmaid’s tale
No, that’s a work of fiction
Yeah let’s not forget who they are, the people in power in Iran. Worst scum on earth.
it’s a shame that when scum fights scum there are so many innocent civilians who will suffer. there are no good guys in this. A little bully with rich parents picked a fight with a big bully and everything that can come out of this will suck.
there are no good guys in this.
There were no “good guys” in World War 2 either, and yet you don’t see people going around squealing “both sides were scum!” At anyone who supported the allied
WWII is a very weird exception. Most people have this mentality for just about every war in history except for WWII and really recent wars. For some reason, in the West history starts and stops with WWII. That is the point of reference for everything, and it’s the only war that’s with a superhero comic lens where there is an ultimate good and an ultimate evil… but that’s not really how history works.
Agreed.
I give preference to Iranian civilians because it’s a lot harder for them to relocate than it is for Israelis.
A fair assessment IMO.
Is it normal to allow people to send military information to your enemy?
I’m not a huge fan of either of the two belligerent, but this is not exactly an unreasonable position to take. And they are at least putting reporters on notice.
I mean if they really just wanted to make sure military information doesn’t reach Israel they wouldn’t impose the death penalty; the excessive punishment makes it clear this is going to be used to suppress unrelated dissent.
Information flow can never go backwards. There’s plenty of examples of reporters or even social media compromising military operations. In at least a few cases, it has lead to the destruction of military assets. Once broadcast, the damage is done.
Trying to force reporters to think hard about what they are broadcasting is a good thing, from the point of view of national defence.
“hey, so if we think you published classified info, you’re gonna get killed. Is that okay with you guys? Thanks for being so understanding.”
If it’s a dictatorship I’d say yes because they are (also) the enemy.
I’m also against the death penalty in general, but especially for scaring your own citizens into obedience.
Yeah, apparently murder is supposed to be used for scaring foreign citizens into obedience, based on what liberals say
Removed by mod
Not the worst scum, that honour goes to the leadership of Israel and the Western leaders supporting their genocide.
And if you think Iran is the only country that executes people who send information to the enemy, you need to crack a history book
As bad as israeli and united snake leaders
Whataboutism is for blaming USA when the Russians have done something bad, not the iranians or Israelis 🤷🏼♀️.
They is no whataboutism. You just have double standard
Israel attacks Iran. Iran which was tolerable to media a few months ago is now the root of all evil.
Talk of manufacturing consent in an unprovoked attack on another country. The scrambling to justify these attacks on Iran is real interesting.
See you tomorrow and the next day for an Iran did this bad thing story. Keep drip feeding that narrative.
When was Iran tolerable? They’re still as much of a fucked up theocracy with a terrible record on human rights as they’ve been since the revolution.
I recall seeing a lot of posts on here praising the leadership whenever they said anything negative about Trump
But that’s about the only stuff positive about Iran I’ve seen on here.
I said tolerable to the media. Been barely discussed in UK media until Israel attacked them, now they’re scrambling to justify it based on how bad Iran is…
I’m not in the UK, but I recall Iran being in the media a lot in China and the US. Back when Trump assassinated one of their generals during his first term, the recurring abductions and rapes of women and young girls by the morality police that sparked nationwide protests, the arms they are providing for Russia in their invasion of Ukraine, and now Israel’s unprovoked attack on Iranian infrastructure and citizens.
What do you expect iran to do want the whole west is imposing severe sanctions harming regular citizens. Iran as no choice but to work with russia. Iran could have been an neutral country if americans, israelis and britosh didn’t support the shah coup
I expect them to stop harming their own civilians, too.
We don’t need to cheer on an oppressive, totalitarian regime just because they’re at odds with another oppressive, totalitarian regime.
Funny, I’ve been saying this for the last three years and liberals have been telling me that that makes me a tankie Putin simp.
Based on your other comment, I’m inclined to agree with the liberals.
I am cheering iran right to self defence not the regime harming their own civilians.
Do you condemn israel starting the war and killing civilians ?
Yes I condemn Israel, this isn’t an either/or type of situation. Both countries are shitty.
Basically nothing for 2 years (the protests ended), and the first term for Trump ended in 2021, so 4 years ago. The only thing I have seen is about arms sales, occasionally and it doesn’t express any opinion other than an Iran drone was used.
In the last few days since the attack, it’s quite a lot about nuclear weapons that may be 2 months, 2 years or a 20 years away, and now about journalists. Basically, the strategy has changed to bumping them up the enemies list to justify the attacks.
We don’t see much about the Syrian leader, as he’s not much of a terrorist now he’s working with the West.
It’s interesting how media can pivot their narratives about who the heroes and villains are at any time, and it’s always in line with government foreign policy.
And they’re less terrible than any country that is supporting Israel’s Holocaust in Gaza.
Israel is terrible, but Iran is one of the few countries in the world that tops them.
-
They funded, supported, and armed Hezbollah in Lebanon hat has helped turn the country into a failed state
-
They funded, supported, and armed the Houthis in Yemen that helped turn the country into a failed state
-
They funded, supported, and armed Zaynabiyoun Brigade and Fatemiyoun DivisionIraq in Syria which helped make Syria’s civil war so much worse
-
They funded, supported, and armed Kataib Hezb Allah, Harakat Hezb Allah al Nujaba, Badr organization, Kataib Sayyad al Shuhada, and Asaib Ahl al Haq in Iraq which turned the country into a failed state
-
They directly helped create the conditions that led to the rise of ISIS in both Iraq and Syria
-
They are openly arming and supporting Russia’s invasion of Ukraine
-
They support and fund Saraya al Ashtar and Saraya al Mukhtar in Bahrain to help destabilize the country
-
They fund, support, and arm the Palestinian Islamic Jihad and Hamas in Palestine to keep the country radical and violent against Israel (funny how Israel and Iran have the same goals here)
-
They supported the brutal Al Assad regime in Syria and helped keep him in power
-
They supported and funded Hezbollah al Hejaz in Saudi Arabia to try and destabilize the country
-
They literally have an entire branch in their military that’s specifically created for the purpose of arming proxy groups to destabilize the region (Quds force)
-
They have been oppressing and killing their own people to such a comical degree that they even make other authoritarian countries uncomfortable
They Idk what planet people on this site live on, but Iran is not a force for good in any capacity. The people who support them are either evil, ignorant, or both.
-
Welp, you convinced me, I now support killing as many Iranians, men women and children, as it takes to save Iranians from the yoke of the Islamic Republic. /s
Waging war on Iran will not improve the situation of any Iranian, even the worst off. Do not use the name of the people who will be slaughtered by the millions for your warmongering propaganda.
Not sure how you got any of that from what I was saying. Feel free to take your black and white worldview somewhere else.
Oh, I just assumed that your parroting of the mainstream media justifications of this war of aggression to be an assent of this war. Sorry, my bad.
This is textbook manufacturing consent. Maybe these people could benefit from a little history on how these people got into power, and what helps keep them in power. Big surprise, the same people that loves to bring up how terrible they are as they attack them.
Sadly, Iran has not been “tolerable to the media” in recent times.
(Example: a few months ago, their courts were discussing whether to sentence a rapper named Tataloo to death for “corruption on earth” - singing about the wrong things.)
Since they are now in war, media freedom in Iran is probably under the table.
Lmao imagine thinking that Iran under the regime of the mullahs has ever had any sort of media freedom
In the UK they were not a problem. Not even discussed until Israel attacked and now they’re scrambling to paint them as the biggest evil to retroactively justify the attacks.
Media freedom is rubbish in Iran. They’re not good guys. However, media is silent on the number of journalists Israel has killed recently, and no, they’re not allowed in Gaza, so the threat of death and lack of freedom seems to apply to the aggressors also.
In reality, they should be clearly communicating this is 2 bad guys fighting this out. It’s obvious who the aggressor is who kicked off another front though.
they should be clearly communicating this is 2 bad guys fighting this out.
Would you say they should teach World War 2 was just bad guys fighting it out? Or are you a hypocrite?
What?
It’s a simple question
You’re going to have to elaborate. I need to understand the logical contortion you went through to muster that question…
Lol. The fact that your evading the question and bringing out the reddit smarm suggests that the answer is that you’re a hypocrite.
Iran which was tolerable to media a few months ago
In what parallel reality do you live in ? It has been classified as one of the worse country for press freedom since years by RSF, they shutdown internet when things get out of hand and banned a lot of social medias.
If you read your sources, you’ll realise Palestine is the worst. “Palestine has become the world’s most dangerous state for journalists, as almost 200 reporters were killed in Gaza by the Israeli army over the first 18 months of war, at least 42 of whom were likely killed due to their work. In the West Bank, where journalists were already the victims of abuses by both the Palestinian Authority and the Israeli occupying forces, Israeli pressure has intensified since 7 October 2023, with an increase in arrests of reporters and obstructions to their work.”
2 bad guys are fighting it out here. One was an aggressor who started this conflict…
Clearly, and i never said the opposite.
Iran which was tolerable to media a few months ago
Why are people upvoting you when you’re wrong?
People on this site are seriously out of touch
I don’t want to be mean but did you live under a rock in 2022-2023?
I said a few months ago. I’m pretty sure 24+ months doesn’t fall under the categorisation of “a few”. Iran has been barely touched upon for years, and now the headlines are rolling about how horrible they are now there is a war to justify.
It has been touched upon for years, then fell off the news wagon because of other events.
The attacks are unjustified, but this narrative of “the media had no problem with Iran” when again, in the past years, executions and state violence carried out by Iran have been reported, is false.
I didn’t say no problem, I said tolerable. You really need to read the dictionary and understand words. You cannot just interpret things how you feel, rather than what the words mean.
Did you not see how quick policy and media narratives switch. Recently they tried to rehabilitate the Syrian leader, who’s group was allied to American enemies, and all of a sudden, he wasn’t that bad, let’s drop sanctions.
You have to realise that, what is good and bad, and what the media tells you is good and bad are two different things. You have to critically challenge the narratives you’re fed.
Mate, I don’t rely on mainstream media to tell me what to think about Iran. I have in-laws there. My partner regularly talks to them.
Iran was always shite and during the protests, the media said as much. When they executed protestors, It got reported upon. There was never a time in which Iran was like anywhere close tolerable. Did UK media not pounce on the Shahed drones to Russia? Come on, mate.
The UK media did not. It was mentioned they were used but with no judgement one way over another. The amount of UK weapons used to execute civilians, to them this is state normal.
Myanmar are Ethiopia are doing much worse to civilians. Saudi are horrific for rights. Those countries are barely mentioned. It’s not about atrocities. It’s about Western foreign policy.
Well fuck UK media then, lol.
Maybe I misunderstood you. I’ve been seeing too many people running defense for Iran these days, and by running defense I don’t mean justifying Iranian retaliation (totally justified to strike back if you’re attacked) but rather defending the Iranian government retroactively.
Both Myanmar and Ethiopia are in active states of civil war. By the very nature of civil war they are doing much worse to their citizens. Iran hasn’t been in a civil war, yet it’s still brutalizing its citizens. Even more than the Saudis.
deleted by creator
I was going to say this is manufacturing consent, but given this is recent news I guess I can’t complain.
based. corporate media should shut the fuck up.
Yeah, this is why I’m not on Iran’s side.
I still want them to hurt Israel as much as possible. My heart goes out to the innocent people of Iran.
Ukraine also does this, by the way, are you going to assert that you’re not on Ukraine’s side?
What about iranians who don’t want to get murdered by israel
My heart goes out to the innocent people of Iran.
Doesn’t look like it. You seems to love seeing Iranians get killed so Israel and the west put a puppet regime instead of the current oppressive regime .
You sound like those people who say my heart going to innocent peoples while defending a genocide in Gaza
Ignored.
