cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/22332949
JD Vance said that āAmerican power comes with certain strings attachedā
cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/22332949
JD Vance said that āAmerican power comes with certain strings attachedā
In the west, you should expect to find the border guard. They are capable of checking databases and patrolling in nature, but arenāt heavily armed. And tens of thousands of guys have taken leave on their own, despite anything the border guard can do. If one doesnāt like the draft, one hikes out via the Carpathian mountains.
As for the draft, yes, itās a real thing. Of course itās unjust, people should be able to live in peace - hence no agressor should invade any land. Having to take up weapons sucks. But when a war on this scale gets started, states will draft soldiers into their armies. Many will dodge it. Since hundreds of thousands of soldiers are needed, lots of mistakes will be made, and will be sorted out later (units donāt actually want soldiers who arenāt capable of fighting).
Ultimately, who was called up but absolutely doesnāt want to fight, must choose among these roles:
Obviously, everyone is not competent to become a medic. The remaining positions are attainable. So, in the end, itās mostly people willing to fight at least somewhat, who end up fighting. Some of them get disillusioned and desert, however. Thatās normal too, in a large war that lasts long. I donāt hold it against them.
Iām not from Ukraine, and not a military person, but I cooperate with military people, supplying drones and stuff that helps bring hostile drones down (profit is not involved). So inevitably I do know the approximate situation.
Iāve read some things by Malatesta before (not much from Goldman), so thanks for the reading tips. There is a nuance, though. Once some country has started a conquest attempt, any disarmament will only give them victory. Disarmament is only possible when itās mutual, and then I fully support it. The article by Goldman that you suggested seems to originate from 1915, when World War I was being fought in Europe. I remind that World War I had no clear agressor, and indeed, anarchists of all countries tried to overthrow the ruling regimes (which were mostly undemocratic, frequently dictatorial and imperial).
The current situation somewhat differs. There is a clear agressor, which happens to be a dictatorship and an empire, supported by other dictatorships and a messed up theocracy. There happens to be a clearly defined victim of agression, which happens to be mostly democratic, supported by places that are reasonably democratic. I believe that if Malatesta lived today, I could convince him to start a charity that supplies Ukrainians. :)
I hope for revolutionary conditions to arise in Russia, but that will be a long wait. My comrades there tried and lost, theyāve mostly emigrated by now. Some are imprisoned, some still keep trying (I canāt estimate what the percentages are, people donāt talk openly of such things), but there are approximately 4 times as much cops per capita in Russia compared to a normal country, so their chances are miserable.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANxo0gBM6GM
In this video you can see soldiers patrolling the borders with rifles and dogs and using drones to scan the area, whatās your definition of heavily armed? They look heavily armed enough to me.
I hope thatās true, according to wikipedia half of the people trying to escape are getting caught
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobilization_in_Ukraine
āSince the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, around 650,000 military-aged men have left the country. According to Ukrainian authorities, as of November 2023, around 20,000 people had been caught while trying to cross the border illegally since February 2022, and another 20,000 successful crossings were recorded between February 2022 and 31 August 2023 according to a BBC Eye Investigation.ā
Malatesta wrote multiple times on the subject.
https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/errico-malatesta-anarchists-have-forgotten-their-principles
https://www.marxists.org/archive/malatesta/1916/pro-government-anarchists.html
The clue here is that soldiers typically donāt have dogs - their job is not tracking anyone. The folks you see are probably border guards. (Another clue is that soldiers would be expected to carry at least one proper machine gun per squad, items like grenades and grenade launchers, etc.)