looking for an old fashioned log cabin in the woods. but the logs that the cabin is built from are turds instead of felled trees. i thought that would be easy. but every image generator i’ve tried. simply ignores the turd part and instead shits out a generic log cabin make of wood. i’ve tried extremely specific and exhaustive prompts. but it doesnt matter how i word the prompts. the output is always some generic variation of a standard wooden cabin. what gives?

  • ✧✨🌿Allo🌿✨✧@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
    81·
    2 months ago

    i find ai is not the best at understanding actual creativity. It has a tendency to see the unusual part of what you are saying and think “that’s abnormal, surely that’s not what is meant, i better do the normal way”. I find in SD1.5, since it’s old, it at least SEEMS creative because of the chaos. But I often go to SDXL or SD3.5 with an extracreative idea I want to be really specifically done perfectly and, instead, it makes a ‘perfect’ image not of what my idea was but of the nearest human commoner concept a noncreative boring person with no creativity would have. As ai modernizes, it seems better at images that don’t think outside the box, and converts prompts outside the box to being within.

    Also I hope my current view is incorrect and I HEAR midjourney (which i haven’t used) is good at prompt specificity

  • talEnglish
    2·
    2 months ago

    Some generators censor certain words. I can imagine that it’s possible that “shit” or similar is in the list.

    EDIT: Some experimentation with a model (realmixXL) that clearly doesn’t in ComfyUI: I can get a log cabin made of shit, especially if I crank down the prompt term weight, but it doesn’t seem to generate logs made of straight feces. I’d guess that maybe there aren’t enough photographs of straight feces to be able to pick up on that as being an option.

    e.g.

    A (log cabin:.7) made of poop in the woods.

    Other substances clearly work:

    A log cabin made of ice in the woods.