DoomBloomDialectic [he/him, they/them]

  • 0 Posts
  • 94 Comments
Joined 2 months ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2025

help-circle

  • site’s bumming me out. late 2022ish - late 2024 really felt like the Golden Age of chabear, vibes been off since then. felt like a genuinely safe space by internet standards for a while, but feels like ambient toxicity has been on a steady incline since last fall. before that most of the hostility was isolated to the struggle sessions - which still sucked and obviously were upsetting for those involved, but generally easy to avoid til they blew over. i just feel like everyone could afford to remind themselves semi-regularly that being Correct Online doesn’t matter 95-99% of the time.

    sorry if this counts as metaposting - tbh i don’t fully understand what metaposting is, or at the very least when it crosses over into rule breaking territory vs. just informally talking about the site. it’s cool if this post needs to get got, this online shit doesn’t really matter at the end of the day. and maybe that hits the core of the issue, that the internet broadly is what’s bumming me out more than hexbear specifically thinky-felix












  • well…IMO the book does a better job of depicting its full suite of powers nerd

    annoying

    i think it’s primarily supposed to be a tool of mental domination over others, we mostly only really ever see humble creatures like hobbits use it & even then carelessly and unintentionally, the invisibility is more of an unintended, passive fringe ability it has. my understanding is it’s basically a raw, physical piece of Sauron he carved into reality, particularly his naked ambition and selfishness, and someone like Gandalf, Saruman, Galadriel, or even Aragorn would have been able to harness more of its true power the way Sauron did (i.e the power to dominate others’ wills). but since it’s just a raw piece of malice and selfish hatred, even if they beat Sauron this way they’d just be warped into evil tyrants themselves.

    in the books there’s a portion where Frodo seems to grow in stature and become a great lord when he demands gollum swear an oath not to hurt him again, implying its powers of dominance rubbed off on him even w/o Frodo intending to use it.

    IIRC the canon reason for the invisibility is it puts mortal creatures closer to the realm of spirits/wraiths, but since Sauron and the wizards are Maiar (lesser angels) they’re already spirits manifested physically and would simply be able to use it as intended. the Doylist reason though, is just that the hobbit wasn’t originally intended to be part of the LOTR universe, so the lil magic ring that turns you invisible had to be retconned into this world ending artifact of extreme power.

    idk, i think it’s pretty cool - even though the the movies dropped the ball in adapting some of this i still feel like it comes through that the invisibility is just scratching the surface, and the ring carries an air of mystique & dread. plus i like how its seductive power is depicted in the movies, and the how it always seems heavier than its size would warrant. i do also feel like they could have adapted some if its other powers more directly and that was a missed opportunity, like the scene of Frodo dominating Gollum would have been really cinematic & cool in the medium of film.








  • yeah for me, i think the assuming of worst faith, jumping down people’s throats for innocuous shit (or at least, non-ill-intended shit), and dunking/owning/winning arguments as a form of currency just feel too baked into the cultural architecture of the medium of the internet to fully escape it. hexbear is generally a lot better than the rest of what’s out there, but it’s not immune by any means.

    and as far as the explicitly political end of the internet, the mistaking of doing discourse/having the correct opinions online for actually Doing Politics/being a political actor is also kind of inherent. again, people are a lot more cognizant of that trap on this site than others, but it’s still baked in to a degree.

    i’d probably follow your example of shooting for once a week of internet time, but i have a high downtime job in front of a computer most of the day. so here i am shrug-outta-hecks