Whenever I hear about D&D more often than not it seems like people go to great lengths to stay in character and roleplay

This is great and makes for some very interesting stories but I tend to find myself more interested in just going on an adventure with a group of friends, solve a few puzzles win a few fights, complete a few quests etc

I’m also a big fan of character optimisation and mechanics but get the feeling that can be frowned upon by much of the community

Difficult to describe what I mean here but as an example in baldur’s gate I barely roleplay at all, my character has no personality except for the fact they make the decisions I would make, but I find that more fun, not having to worry about what my character would do and just making the decision I want to make

I realise not having a fleshed out character in D&D detracts from the immersiveness of the story because the DM can’t weave your character into the story but at least at the moment that doesn’t sound too bad to me.

Just wondering if there are people out there who run lighter roleplay campaigns

  • chillhelm@lemmy.world
    141·
    11 months ago

    War gaming can be fun, but I don’t think DnD is especially geared toward it

    Isn’t like 90% of the rules for DnD just rules for combat and treasure? Literally every single class in DnD is a combat class. And when people talk about their DnD characters they say “I played this Dragonborn Cleric…” or “Multiclassed Tiefling Mage/Rouge” and not “I played this Dwarf that had really good proficiency in Persuasion and ‘Use Rope’”. [Btw is ‘Use Rope’ still a skill in newer DnD editions?].

    • Sentrovasi@kbin.social
      5·
      11 months ago

      Yeah I was going to say: D&D is a lot more geared towards numbers and combat encounters than many other TTRPG systems. My main issue is actually finding players who want to engage in the co-creation of story rather than combat optimisation (not that they preclude each other, but oftentimes if you’ve built your character as a hammer, everything can start to look like a nail).

    • Ekky@sopuli.xyz
      3·
      11 months ago

      The current DnD system does definitely have a combat system and enough rules to get you started, though it’s way less rule-heavy than most Warhammer, Shadowrunner, and even previous DnD PnP systems I’ve played. It feels more like starting guidelines than a proper system.

      I’ve considered playing stars without numbers and Fate Core, which should apparently be a very rule-light PnP system, though haven’t gotten around to them yet.