How is it possible, that Signal still only provides a .deb package and no .rpm, or even better AppImage or Flatpak? There is an unofficial Flatpak but is it secure?

  • @theorangeninjaOP
    link
    512 days ago

    They should provide an app for other distros then!

    • @Hirom@beehaw.org
      link
      fedilink
      3
      edit-2
      12 days ago

      They can’t possibly provide a package for every distro.

      Signal’s model, ie keep tight control over development and distribution of the client, and the absence of federation, it well suited for Apple/Google’s stores, but not at all for open-source and Linux’ ecosystem.

      • @theorangeninjaOP
        link
        912 days ago

        AppImages run on nearly every distro. Why arw they not providing that instead of a .deb?

        • @Hirom@beehaw.org
          link
          fedilink
          412 days ago

          Yes, AppImage can run on more distro.

          Still AppImage has disadvantages over DEB: No auto-update, No/less system integration, Bigger install packages.

      • @ulkesh@beehaw.org
        link
        fedilink
        English
        812 days ago

        You are right. They can’t for every distro.

        But fedora/rhel, Ubuntu/debian, and arch-based distros are the most commonly used. So they can provide official packages for those, and/or as the OP said, provide an official flatpak.

        And to be fair, it’s a nice-to-have to have a better sense of trust, but given the unofficial ones are open source, it’s quite likely any maliciousness would be rooted out very quickly.

        • TimLovesTech (AuDHD)(he/him)
          link
          fedilink
          English
          211 days ago

          Or, if you are running one of those distros you could just take the .deb and repackage it for whatever distro you’re running. Expecting a project to package for every distro, and then be required to support them for every release is a lot of work. And unfortunately some people have no issues expecting from others, but baulk at the idea of doing it themselves.