• @juicyOP
    link
    73 months ago

    If you supply someone with a weapon that you know will be used to kill their spouse, you will be charged with murder.

    • mozz
      link
      fedilink
      183 months ago

      Unsurprisingly, this isn’t true.

      There’s actually a much more accurate fleshing out of analogy that could be made – helping a friend in a violent situation, and enabling them to do violent criminal things but still trying to stop them once it came to the point of killing, and what crime you’d get charged with for that – but that construction would lead in the direction of nuance, so juicy doesn’t want that.

      • @juicyOP
        link
        9
        edit-2
        3 months ago

        US: Here’s a bullet. Please don’t use it to kill a child.

        Israel: I’ll do what I want.

        Israel shoots a toddler.

        US: Oh, why’d you do that?! Here’s another bullet. This time, please only use it for legitimate self-defence.

        Israel: That was self-defence.

        Israel shoots a baby

        Bystander: Stop that!

        US: (to bystander) Mind your own business. (to Israel) Here’s another bullet. Now please, no more kids.

        Israel shoots pregnant mother

        Is that nuanced enough for you?

        • mozz
          link
          fedilink
          21
          edit-2
          3 months ago

          This analysis, I pretty much exactly agree with. That all makes it notable that under Biden they put sanctions on settlers for the first time in history and didn’t veto a security council attempt to reign in Israel for the first time I’m aware of.

          Is that enough? No. Does it excuse 5 months of exactly what you’re describing, is it any help to someone whose child starved to death while Biden was gradually coming around in his own time, does it guarantee that anything will happen in the future that isn’t just more of the same grim neoliberal encouragement and funding for the slaughter of the browns? No, no, and no.

          Are those still relevant facts, though? Yes. Are you posting all this out of any good well intentioned concern for the well being of the Palestinians, or with consideration of the fact that Trump explicitly wants to go in and finish the genocide instead of this limp-wristed-too-late opposition Biden is giving? That one, only you can answer.

          • Admiral Patrick
            link
            fedilink
            English
            13
            edit-2
            3 months ago

            I appreciate you taking the time/effort to do the fact checking on these accounts (here and in other threads). I try when I can, but my time is limited by 10,000 things vying for it.

            FWIW, that account is 2 3 weeks old and exists on an instance that has been springing up trolls left and right because it has wide-open registrations.

        • frog 🐸
          link
          fedilink
          English
          03 months ago

          Just to play Devil’s advocate here… The US takes that approach to guns inside its own borders, expecting that asking nicely is enough to stop people shooting up schools. So it would be kinda hypocritical for the US to hold Israel to different standards. Guns are America’s real religion.