There’s no way for teachers to figure out if students are using ChatGPT to cheat, OpenAI says in new back-to-school guide::AI detectors used by educators to detect use of ChatGPT don’t work, says OpenAI.

  • Extras
    link
    English
    10
    edit-2
    10 months ago

    Havent read the article yet but guess teacher’s best option is to go back to paper and do all of their work during class period. Not sure how they’ll handle homework though or outside projects

    • @TropicalDingdong@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      -1110 months ago

      And what is this suppose to teach the students in a world where you can plug a prompt into a machine and get most of a right answer?

      This leaves the students behind and uncompetetive for a world that is different from the one their teachers grew up in.

      • Dojan
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1110 months ago

        Zoe Bee did a video essay on how the modern education system (which really isn’t much different from the one we had 100 years ago) is kind of flawed.

        I rather hope that the advent of AI tools will force education to evolve away from the broken systems we have today.

      • Extras
        link
        English
        8
        edit-2
        10 months ago

        I dont mean to be rude or anything but if I understand correctly what youre saying is dont teach them anything but how to input questions into a text field, right? Its the same old statement as “Why learn basic math if calculators exist” do you not see the problem there? Sure you get the answer but you wont understand what any of it means which will hinder the knowlege that humanity gained through the thousands of years they been on this earth. Thats a horrible take and I pray you understand why. I do agree that technology is a great tool and should be taught how to be used in school, it shouldn’t be the only method of getting answers, thats just dumb and hurts everyone in the future.

        Edit: again my opinion agree or diagree

        • @TropicalDingdong@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          -510 months ago

          “Why learn basic math if calculators exist”

          If you are spending your time writing and solving equations, and many students currently are being ‘taught’ that way, you are being taught math incorrectly. This technology disrupts that same principal on the writing and regurgitation of information side of learning. As an excercise for ChatGPT, I’m going to ask it to outline an essay on the fluid dynamics of low silica vulcansim and see what it comes up with. The exact prompt I’m going to use is. “Hi Chat GPT. I’m begining the process of writing an essay on the flue dynamics of low silica vulcanism. I realize this may require some very domain specific knowledge, so I’ll be providing you with information and asking you to clarify sections later. In this first attempt, I’d like you to cover the issue in the broadest way, but please get highly specific in sections that I should cover. I would like a high amount of detail in this outline. Please also give me key words and phrases to search for for each sub-point of the outline.”

          Here is ChatGPTs response:

          —start—

          Essay Outline on Fluid Dynamics of Low Silica Vulcanism I. Introduction

          Brief background on volcanic activity
          Importance of studying fluid dynamics in volcanism
          The specific focus on low silica vulcanism
          Thesis Statement: Unveiling how the unique fluid dynamics of low-silica magmatic systems influence the characteristics and behavior of corresponding volcanic eruptions.
          

          Keywords for Research: Introduction to volcanism, Importance of fluid dynamics in volcanology, Low silica vs. high silica magma II. Basic Principles of Fluid Dynamics in Geology

          Navier-Stokes Equations
          Reynolds Number
          Non-Newtonian fluids in geology
          Importance in volcanic contexts
          

          Keywords for Research: Navier-Stokes Equations in geology, Reynolds number in magma flow, Non-Newtonian fluids in Earth science, Fluid dynamics in volcanology III. Classification of Magmatic Systems

          High-silica vs. Low-silica magmatic systems
          Composition and its impact on fluid dynamics
          Physical properties: viscosity, temperature, and gas content
          Geological settings prone to low silica vulcanism
          

          Keywords for Research: Magmatic systems, Silica content in magma, Magmatic properties, Geological settings of low silica vulcanism IV. Fluid Dynamics of Low Silica Magma A. Viscosity

          Definition and significance
          Comparison with high-silica systems
          Impact on flow and eruption style
          

          Keywords for Research: Viscosity of low-silica magma, Viscosity comparison in magmatic systems, Influence of viscosity on volcanic eruptions B. Temperature

          Typical temperature ranges
          Influence on fluidity and eruption
          Interplay between temperature and other physical properties
          

          Keywords for Research: Temperature of low-silica magma, Influence of temperature on viscosity and fluidity, Temperature and eruption dynamics C. Gas Content

          Types of gases involved
          Role in explosivity and effusivity
          Effects on magma ascent and fragmentation
          

          Keywords for Research: Gas content in low-silica magma, Role of gases in volcanic eruptions, Gas-driven magma ascent D. Laminar vs. Turbulent Flow

          Conditions leading to each type
          Implications for eruption style and deposits
          

          Keywords for Research: Laminar flow in low-silica magma, Turbulent flow in magma, Flow regimes and eruption style V. Real-world Examples and Case Studies

          Specific volcanoes that have exhibited low silica vulcanism
          Summary of eruptions, flow patterns, and consequences
          Importance of understanding these cases for hazard mitigation
          

          Keywords for Research: Low-silica volcanoes, Case studies of low silica vulcanism, Volcanic hazard mitigation VI. Implications for Planetary Volcanism

          Extrapolating Earth’s models to other celestial bodies
          Examples: Venus, Mars, and Moon
          Utility in astrobiology and planetary science
          

          Keywords for Research: Planetary volcanism, Venus volcanism, Mars volcanism, Extraterrestrial applications of fluid dynamics VII. Conclusion

          Summary of key findings
          Importance of further research in the field
          Broader implications for geology and human society
          

          Keywords for Research: Summary of fluid dynamics in low-silica vulcanism, Future research avenues, Societal importance of understanding volcanic systems VIII. References IX. Appendices

          Tables, charts, and additional data
          

          Feel free to adjust the outline as needed, and don’t hesitate to reach out if you have specific sections you would like me to clarify or expand upon.

          —end—

          I don’t necessarily know what the right answer is, but I know that the wrong answer is to stick our (as a teacher of sorts) collective heads in the sand and pretend that this isn’t a game changing technology for most sectors. I tell my students and mentees to absolute use ChatGPT. That response took ChatGPT about 15 seconds. Its probably more than good enough for me to write a decent essay on.

          If you aren’t using ChatGPT or teaching your students to use this technology, then you are doing them a disservice.

          • @kent_eh@lemmy.ca
            link
            fedilink
            English
            110 months ago

            Being able to asses if the answer you got from the AI tool is reasonable relies on your ability to understand how to get to that answer.

            And, believe it or not, there will be times when a person might not have access to an AI tool to answer their questions, and they might need to be able to come up with their own answer independently.

      • @Ringmasterincestuous@aussie.zone
        link
        fedilink
        English
        410 months ago

        This is true… we should be teaching them prompt skills and utilising it every day. Then pay wall the fuck out of it on the day of exams…

        Should prepare them nicely 😏

      • @atzanteol@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        English
        210 months ago

        And what is this suppose to teach the students in a world where you can plug a prompt into a machine and get most of a right answer?

        How to determine when that response is not correct.